Amazon.com: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Suede Matte Lip Liner, Vegan Formula - Softspoken (Ash Rose)
Matte Fix Lip Pencil – about-face
kiss new york Professional Slim Lip Pencil Creamy Soft Lip Liner Smooth Long-Lasting Rich Lip Color Natural Lip Makeup Water-Resistant Lip Crayon (Nude Truffle)
looking for a dupe, essence soft & precise lip pencil, shade - 21 charming : r/MakeupAddiction
Lip Pencil – Soft | NakedPoppy
Kiss New York Professional Silky Smooth Lip Pencil Liner, Creamy Soft Lip Liner, Smooth Long-Lasting Rich Lip Color, Natural Lip Makeup, Water Resistant Lip Crayon